What If the Best Way to Lower America's Healthcare Costs Is to Need Less Healthcare?

America spent $5.3 trillion on healthcare in 2024. This is the demand-side question the debate keeps skipping: how much of that need could be prevented — and what does food have to do with it? By Mike Johnston and Athena.

A homemade roast chicken dinner on a rustic table, a tall stack of paper bills beside it, and a hazy hospital building in the background

By Mike Johnston and Athena

We’re Asking the Wrong Question About Healthcare

Every year, Americans argue about healthcare.

We argue about insurance premiums, deductibles, prescription drug prices, government programs, hospital bills, and who should pay for what.

Politicians promise to make healthcare more affordable. Insurance companies negotiate with hospitals. Employers struggle with rising benefit costs. Families worry about whether they can afford to get sick.

But there’s a fundamental economic question that rarely receives the attention it deserves:

What if we could lower healthcare costs by reducing the amount of healthcare Americans need?

Not by denying treatment. Not by making insurance harder to obtain. And certainly not by suggesting that sick people are responsible for their illnesses.

By helping more people stay healthy in the first place.

It sounds almost embarrassingly simple.

But when we examine the economics of American healthcare, the implications become enormous.

The $5.3 Trillion Problem

According to the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services, the United States spent approximately $5.3 trillion on healthcare in 2024.

That’s about $15,474 for every person in the country.

Healthcare consumed 18% of the entire American economy.

Think about that.

Nearly one out of every five dollars of economic activity is devoted to healthcare.

And the amount continues to grow.

Much of the discussion about these numbers focuses on the price of medical services. That’s certainly important. American healthcare is expensive for reasons that include hospital pricing, administrative complexity, prescription costs, and insurance arrangements.

But there’s another factor.

Demand.

The more medical services a population requires, the greater the pressure on the system providing them.

And Americans require an extraordinary amount of medical care.

The Economics of an Unhealthy Population

Economics teaches us that prices are influenced by supply and demand.

Healthcare is more complicated than an ordinary consumer market. Insurance, negotiated prices, government payments, emergency treatment requirements, and regional hospital competition all affect what patients and insurers pay.

Nevertheless, the underlying relationship matters.

When more people need medical attention, the system must provide more appointments, medications, diagnostic tests, hospital beds, procedures, and ongoing treatment.

That requires more doctors, nurses, technicians, facilities, equipment, and money.

Expanding healthcare capacity is important.

But what if we could also reduce some of the demand?

Consider a patient who develops type 2 diabetes.

That diagnosis may begin years of blood tests, medical appointments, medications, and monitoring.

Some patients eventually develop complications affecting their kidneys, eyesight, nerves, or cardiovascular system.

These complications can be devastating for the individual and enormously expensive to treat.

Now imagine preventing some of those cases before they occur.

The patient benefits.

Their family benefits.

And the healthcare system avoids some of the costs associated with managing the disease.

Multiply that possibility across millions of Americans, and the economic implications become substantial.

Chronic Disease Is Driving an Enormous Share of Healthcare Spending

The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention reports that approximately 90% of American healthcare expenditures are for people with chronic and mental health conditions.

That statistic requires an important distinction.

It does not mean 90% of healthcare spending is preventable. Many chronic illnesses have genetic, environmental, infectious, developmental, or other causes beyond an individual’s control.

It also does not mean all the spending associated with someone who has a chronic condition is caused by that condition.

But it demonstrates how closely healthcare spending is connected to the ongoing treatment needs of people living with long-term health problems.

And some of those problems are influenced by modifiable risk factors.

Poor nutrition, physical inactivity, smoking, excessive alcohol consumption, and excess body weight contribute to substantial burdens of preventable disease.

We cannot eliminate chronic illness.

But we can reduce the risk of certain diseases, delay their development, and improve the health of people already living with them.

That deserves far more attention in our national healthcare debate.

Diabetes: A $413 Billion Example

Consider diabetes.

The American Diabetes Association estimated that diagnosed diabetes cost the United States $412.9 billion in 2022.

That included approximately $306.6 billion in direct medical costs and another $106.3 billion in indirect costs, including lost productivity.

People with diagnosed diabetes incurred average medical expenditures approximately 2.6 times higher than would be expected without the disease.

These are staggering numbers.

And type 2 diabetes, which accounts for the great majority of diabetes cases, is a condition whose development can often be delayed or prevented in people at elevated risk.

One of the most important demonstrations came from the National Institutes of Health’s Diabetes Prevention Program.

Participants in an intensive lifestyle intervention reduced their risk of developing type 2 diabetes by 58% over approximately three years, compared with participants receiving a placebo.

Among participants aged 60 and older, the reduction was 71%.

The intervention emphasized weight management, healthier eating, and physical activity.

It wasn’t a miracle drug.

It wasn’t an experimental medical procedure.

It was a structured program helping people change everyday habits.

And it worked.

Now consider the potential consequences if effective prevention became a much larger part of American healthcare.

Fewer people developing diabetes could eventually mean fewer complications, fewer hospitalizations, and less demand for some expensive medical treatments.

That wouldn’t eliminate healthcare inflation, but it could reduce a significant source of avoidable suffering and expenditure.

Where Carbohydrates Enter the Picture

One important part of this discussion is the modern American diet.

We live in a food environment filled with sweetened beverages, refined starches, oversized portions, and inexpensive, heavily processed foods.

For many people, consuming excessive calories and large amounts of refined carbohydrates makes weight management and blood glucose control more difficult.

This doesn’t mean carbohydrates are inherently unhealthy.

Vegetables, fruit, beans, and whole grains contain carbohydrates and can be valuable parts of a nutritious diet.

The distinction is between the amount and quality of carbohydrates consumed, an individual’s metabolic health, and the overall composition of their diet.

Research has shown that reducing carbohydrate intake can improve blood glucose management for some people with type 2 diabetes.

The American Diabetes Association recognizes carbohydrate reduction as one dietary option for improving glycemic control.

However, research also indicates that benefits vary, and some advantages diminish over time. Low-carbohydrate diets are not universally superior to other well-designed eating patterns.

That variability is not a footnote — it’s one of the best-documented findings in modern nutrition research. Two people can eat the same meal and get very different blood-sugar responses, which is why your carb number isn’t on the chart: it’s personal, and you find it by paying attention to your own responses, not by reading a table.

The most effective approach is one that supports good nutrition, fits an individual’s medical needs, and can be maintained.

That last point is particularly important.

A diet that works for three weeks but cannot be sustained for three years isn’t much of a long-term solution.

And that’s where the way we prepare food becomes important.

What If Healthier Food Didn’t Taste Like Diet Food?

For decades, Americans have been offered supposedly healthier substitutes for familiar foods.

Low-fat products. Sugar-free products. Keto products. Protein-enriched products.

Some are excellent.

Others bear only a passing resemblance to the foods they’re intended to replace.

Anyone who has tried a disappointing low-carb bread or a dry, gritty keto cookie understands the problem.

People enjoy food.

They enjoy warm bread, homemade cookies, pizza, pasta, cinnamon rolls, and family dinners.

Food is part of our culture, our traditions, and our memories.

Telling people to abandon everything they enjoy is unlikely to produce lasting dietary change.

But what if we approached the problem differently?

What if we could make familiar foods with substantially fewer carbohydrates while preserving the flavor and texture people love?

Not necessarily zero carbohydrates.

Not necessarily ketogenic.

Just meaningfully fewer carbohydrates without sacrificing the pleasure of eating.

Imagine homemade chocolate chip cookies with considerably less sugar.

Or fresh bread formulated to contain fewer digestible carbohydrates.

Or pizza dough that tastes like traditional pizza dough rather than a substitute.

These foods would still need sensible portions and balanced nutritional profiles. Lower carbohydrate content doesn’t automatically make a food healthy.

But making healthier choices more enjoyable could help people maintain dietary improvements over time.

And sustainable changes are what matter.

Prevention Is Also an Economic Investment

Suppose a person improves their diet, becomes more physically active, and reduces their risk of developing type 2 diabetes.

The immediate benefit belongs to that individual.

But the potential benefits extend further.

They may experience fewer medical complications, remain productive longer, and require less treatment over their lifetime.

At a population level, those improvements could reduce demand for certain healthcare services.

This doesn’t mean every preventive intervention saves money.

Some prevention programs cost more than the medical expenditures they avert, even while producing substantial health benefits.

And people who live longer may eventually require additional healthcare for other conditions.

But the objective shouldn’t be to eliminate medical spending.

It should be to produce better health outcomes while using resources more effectively.

A healthcare system that prevents avoidable disease is serving its population better than one focused almost exclusively on treating illness after it develops.

We Still Need Healthcare Reform

None of this eliminates the need to address the structural problems of American healthcare.

Hospital consolidation, administrative costs, insurance complexity, prescription drug pricing, workforce shortages, and unequal access to medical care all deserve serious attention.

A healthier population would not automatically force hospitals or insurers to lower their prices.

Nor would it eliminate the need for medical professionals.

Americans will always need healthcare.

People develop cancer despite healthy lifestyles. Genetic diseases affect families. Accidents happen. Infectious diseases spread. Bodies age.

And many people living with chronic conditions already do everything reasonably possible to protect their health.

They deserve effective, affordable treatment without judgment.

But recognizing these realities doesn’t diminish the value of prevention.

It strengthens the case for pursuing both approaches simultaneously.

We need healthcare that is more affordable when people become sick.

And we need a society that makes it easier for people to stay healthy.

What Would Happen If Millions of Americans Became Healthier?

Imagine a country where millions of people gradually improved their diets.

Where more people maintained healthy blood glucose levels.

Where fewer people developed preventable cases of type 2 diabetes.

Where physical activity became part of everyday life.

Where healthier foods were affordable, accessible, and enjoyable.

The benefits would extend beyond healthcare spending.

People might experience more energy, greater mobility, better quality of life, and more years of independence.

Families could spend less time managing preventable complications.

Employers might experience less illness-related absenteeism.

Healthcare professionals could devote more resources to conditions that cannot readily be prevented.

And over time, some of the financial pressure created by chronic disease could ease.

We cannot responsibly predict exactly how much money such changes would save without detailed economic modeling.

But the possibility deserves serious investigation.

Especially in a country spending trillions of dollars annually on healthcare.

A Different Way to Think About Healthcare Costs

The American healthcare debate usually begins with a financial question:

Who is going to pay?

Should employers pay more?

Should individuals pay more?

Should insurance companies pay less?

Should government programs expand?

These are legitimate questions.

But perhaps we should begin with another:

Why do we need so much healthcare, and how much of that need could we safely prevent?

Not every illness can be avoided.

Not every medical expense can be reduced.

And no single diet will solve America’s healthcare crisis.

But improving nutrition, reducing preventable disease, and helping people maintain healthier lifestyles could be part of a much larger solution.

We should be willing to explore that possibility with the same seriousness we devote to insurance reform and medical pricing.

Because the best healthcare outcome isn’t necessarily receiving excellent treatment.

Sometimes, it’s never needing that treatment in the first place.


Why We Created LoCarbLife

LoCarbLife grew from a simple belief:

Eating fewer carbohydrates shouldn’t mean giving up the foods you love.

We’re interested in developing homemade recipes that preserve traditional flavor and texture while reducing carbohydrates where practical.

We’re not promoting extreme dietary restrictions or claiming that low-carb eating is right for everyone.

We simply believe that making healthier food more enjoyable can help people make lasting changes.

And lasting changes, multiplied across millions of people, have the potential to improve more than individual health.

They could help change the economics of healthcare itself.

Real food. Homemade taste. Fewer carbs.

That’s LoCarbLife.


References

  1. Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services. National Health Expenditure Data, 2024. U.S. healthcare expenditures reached $5.3 trillion ($15,474 per person), representing 18.0% of GDP.
  2. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Health and Economic Costs of Chronic Conditions (Fast Facts). Chronic and mental health conditions are associated with approximately 90% of U.S. healthcare expenditures.
  3. American Diabetes Association. “Economic Costs of Diabetes in the U.S. in 2022.” Diabetes Care, 2024. Estimated annual economic burden: $412.9 billion ($306.6 billion direct medical costs, $106.3 billion indirect costs).
  4. Knowler WC, et al.; Diabetes Prevention Program Research Group. “Reduction in the Incidence of Type 2 Diabetes with Lifestyle Intervention or Metformin.” New England Journal of Medicine, 2002. Intensive lifestyle intervention reduced type 2 diabetes incidence by 58% versus placebo over approximately three years (71% among participants aged 60 and older). Program summary: National Institute of Diabetes and Digestive and Kidney Diseases, Diabetes Prevention Program.
  5. American Diabetes Association. Standards of Care in Diabetes—2026. Reviews evidence for individualized dietary approaches, including carbohydrate reduction for glycemic control.
  6. Davies MJ, et al. “Management of Hyperglycemia in Type 2 Diabetes, 2022. A Consensus Report by the American Diabetes Association (ADA) and the European Association for the Study of Diabetes (EASD).” Diabetes Care, 2022. Discusses dietary quality, sustainable eating patterns, and individualized nutritional management.

Editorial note: This article is intended for general education and discussion. It does not provide individualized medical advice. People managing diabetes or taking glucose-lowering medications should consult their healthcare professionals before making substantial dietary changes.

Nutrition note: any carb figures mentioned are estimates derived from data published by the manufacturers of the ingredients used. Check your own ingredients for exact numbers.